Post from Peter Koltak's Blog:
Kilroy vs. Brooks vs. Pryce?

OH-15: Today's Dispatch has an interesting piece:

"We could have a primary," Brooks acknowledged.

She returned yesterday from Washington, where she attended the National Association of Counties’ annual legislative conference.

Off-hours, she courted officials of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee.

"I got a very good reception," she said.

Also yesterday, Kilroy announced that she was planning a rematch against U.S. Rep. Deborah Pryce, R-Upper Arlington. She began asking supporters this week for donations.

To summarize: Kilroy is in officially and Brooks unofficially. It is very early, but neither of them sounds of if they are planning on backing down from this race. That obviously leave us with a potentially contested primary.  I'm not personally going to voice and opinion because I like, respect, and have good relationships with both women.

But I will say a few things that I don't like about about a contested primary scenario:

1. It leaves two county commission seats undefended. We have our collective foot on the throat of the FCRP. The only position of any consequence outside of judges they still hold is the county auditor. I don't like potentially handling them a big homerun to revitalize a faltering county party

2. Money--this one is going to cost the big bucks, and I don't want to see our eventual nominee wasting valuable $$ on a primary. Remember, it's about taking the seat in November, not in March. Also, unless Pryce drops out, there is little change of an R primary. We don't want our candidate weakened by a primary.

3. It pits two powerful and important women in the Franklin County party against one another. I hate to lose one of them to service in the federal government, but I would especially hate to see  them both out of government at the local level. It puts incredible pressure on Marilyn Brown (the remaining commissioner) to campaign hard and get two new colleagues for herself elected. 

This debate has been raging at BSB here and here. I'd love to know what readers here think about the OH-15 race. At the very least, Pryce has got to be sweating that fact that in less than 6 months from her last election, she potentially has already got two strong challengers coming for her.


Reader Comments
  
Good analysis
By Doug Mar 9th 2007 at 10:08 am EST
I think you sum things up well. I'm wondering if an appointment to the Strickland Admin. of either Kilroy or Brooks could be a release valve? Do County Commissioner vacancies work like Cols. City Council vacancies? That can get abused but this is a unique situation.

Unfortunately, these things get decided by the power brokers. I don't know the the positions on the issues of either Brooks or Kilroy to have a preference. But, usually candidates get one shot and someone else gets an at-bat next time around.
Pryce was and is very beatable.

Another alternative is to seek a non-Commissioner Candidate. State Rep. Dan Stewart has progressive values and got re-elected last year with 70% of the vote. He would make a great U.S. Congressman.
Dan Stewart
By Jump23 Mar 9th 2007 at 12:08 pm EST
I like Rep. Stewart a lot and I realize he is popular, but to win in his district and to win in House 15 are two _very_ different things. I continue to believe that if you are going to win in 15, you need to be seen as somewhat moderate. That was one of the reasons that Mary Jo lost, IMHO.
  
Dan is a fantastic rep
By Peter Mar 9th 2007 at 12:19 pm EST
but part of that is the fact that he is able to get personal in his district. the 15th is too big for that kind of politics and our county comissioners have better name rec across the board. i do think dan will be a great candidate for high office in the future though.
  
Dan Stewart
By Swordfish Mar 22nd 2007 at 12:10 am EDT
Stewart has been a strong supporter of Mary Jo Kilroy and is supporting her again in 2008.
  



PD, AP, Dispatch write-ups of Strickland Budget Speech
By: Bret Thompson, ProgressOhio
Posted Dec 1, 03:02 PM
Comments (0)
Epic Belt Tightening for Ohio's Budget
By: Bret Thompson, ProgressOhio
Posted Dec 1, 02:03 PM
Comments (0)
LIVE VIDEO: Press Briefing with Gov. Strickland and Budget Director
By: Lorraine Bieber
Posted Dec 1, 12:57 PM
Comments (0)
New Compact Turbine Could Triple Wind Power Output
By: User from Struthers, OH
Posted Dec 1, 11:37 AM
Comments (0)
Charity Check
By: OHliz
Posted Nov 30, 12:01 PM
Comments (0)
Lame Duck Mischief
By: User from Hudson, OH
Posted Nov 30, 10:21 AM
Comments (0)
re: dog
As the Baltimore Sun dog blogger pointed during the primarie...
re:
The most interesting/controversial/extr eme measure I'm awar...
Good topic
How can we help the homeless? It's my understanding that man...
Perhaps...
Perhaps, this Charter School Policy could provide improvemen...
The Economic Crisis
As we see today our economy has fall down and most of the th...
Obama's Plans..
After winning the 2008 U.S Election, the big question now is...

Login
Don't have an account yet?
Create Account























Preview | Powered by FeedBlitz




Enter your Email