Grendell, Coughlin will push to standardize eminent domain, further erode home rule

Before providing a link to the GOP announcement about this legislation, I want to emphasize that, for Ohio-oriented news that I know I don't usually see elsewhere first, please be sure you're reading Bill Sloat's The Daily Bellwether. Fisk it like you might fisk any other blog (he took the buyout from the PD last fall), but absolutely don't miss it if you want to see original and primary source blogging. Agree or disagree with what he has there, but, again, he is blogging about Ohio-related stories that others aren't.

And so it was that I read this post of Bill's and then went to the GOP announcement to find this: 

On Tuesday [tomorrow], [State Senator, R-Cuyahoga Falls, Kevin] Coughlin will introduce a resolution that would place the issue of eminent domain before voters statewide. He hopes that in doing so, Ohioans will support an amendment to the constitution that would ensure the state has the authority it needs to govern the use of eminent domain. The bill Senator [Tim] Grendell [R-Chesterland] will sponsor is intended to be the vehicle by which the General Assembly will establish the uniform standards to apply statewide.

Coughlin noted that because of the home-rule provision in the constitution, municipalities set their own standards for eminent domain proceedings and there is no consistency for property owners between one community and the next.

“I believe Ohio voters want the opportunity to support private property rights at the ballot box,” Coughlin said. “Eminent domain should be used sparingly and only when it benefits the public as a whole. Our laws should reflect that and leave no wiggle room for government to abuse its power.”

“From Lake Erie to the Ohio River, all Ohioans deserve to have their private property rights respected and protected,” Grendell said. 

Okay - so, standardization is becoming a four-letter word, yes?  Or is it?  Sometimes it's hard to figure out. Does it depend on how the legislation is drafted and how it looks after it goes through committee and amendments and reconciliation between both houses of the legislature?

Or are we firmly against anything that erodes home rule?

I'm asking because I'm not sure.  I'd like to know more about how people feel about this topic. What do we believe actually would be best, if we can agree on common interests - which, the way Coughlin is couching this legislation, seems to be what he's trying to appeal to?


Reader Comments
  
Great question
By Redhorse Feb 19th 2007 at 3:20 pm EST
I'm not a knee jerk home rule protectionists, but certainly appreciate its role. There are issues that should be locally decided due to their nature and others that can be applied more universally.

This issue, eminent domain, strikes me as something that could apply evenly across the state assuming, of course, it's written well and with the perspective of property owners.

Still, I'd like to see the final language before signing on. I trust little Coughlin has his hands in.
Re: Great question
By Jill Miller Zimon Feb 19th 2007 at 3:37 pm EST
Agreed - what concerns me is the sneakiness in this announcement. It's not presented as a baldface constitutional amendment. The emphasis is how the legislature is driving it - under the guise that it's what the people want already, kind of sort of, since legislators are promoting it. THAT, my friends, is the value of being in the majority in the legislature - you can push this stuff under the color of it being what the people want because they're the majority.

Not that the effort won't have merit or any merit. I don't know. (Have I said that enough?)

But again, they're looking to the constitution - to change it - as regards eminent domain. Given the crap we've been given lately that are supposed to be amendments to the constitution, I can't imagine what the piece of work will look like.
  



The Nutty ACORN Squirrel Runs From Reporters
By: Dave Harding, ProgressOhio
Posted Nov 19, 02:58 PM
Comments (3)
Boehner Stays As House Minority Leader
By: Dave Harding, ProgressOhio
Posted Nov 19, 01:24 PM
Comments (0)
Palin To Appear On Desperate Housewives Season Finale?
By: Dave Harding, ProgressOhio
Posted Nov 19, 11:45 AM
Comments (1)
Why was voter turnout down compared to 2004?
By: Doug
Posted Nov 19, 02:16 PM
Comments (1)
Andyland can tweak your creativity
By: OHliz
Posted Nov 19, 01:10 PM
Comments (0)
Film with Greg Palast, Ohio's Bob Fitrakis, Brad Friedman, Ken Blackwell...
By: NationOfGandhis
Posted Nov 19, 12:40 PM
Comments (2)
Premature
In absolute numbers, compared to 2004, Democratic turnout wa...

Palast, Fitrakis, Friedman & Co.
Should investigate ACORN similar to Blackwell. ACORN is a ba...

thx dave
thanks Mr. Harding

ACORN fires 2, probing embezzlement
"ACORN board's actions will lead to a criminal investigation...

Contagious Nutty Squirrel Disease
Did ACORN irresponsibly spread these germs to unwary sub-pri...

No, wait a minute, the real question is:
"Is Obama the Antichrist?" From Newsweek, so it must be tru...

Login
Don't have an account yet?
Create Account























Preview | Powered by FeedBlitz




Enter your Email